California Court of Appeals Rules Plaintiffs Can Pursue Claims Against Novartis for Alleged Damages Arising From Ingestion of Generic Drug Six Years After Novartis Divested its Interest

March 15, 2016
/
Damages Labeling
/

On March 9, 2016, the California Court of Appeals ruled that the plaintiffs’ claims of failure to warn and misrepresentation against Novartis were legally viable. The critical dispute raised by Novartis was that it did not manufacture the prescription medication that allegedly harmed the plaintiffs. In T. H. v. Novartis Pharms. Corp., No. D067839, 2016 Cal. App. LEXIS 179 (Ct. App. Mar. 9, 2016), two minor plaintiffs alleged that Novartis was liable for neurological injuries they sustained in utero after their mother was prescribed,…
Continue reading...

This Week’s Life Science Headlines

March 14, 2014
/
Design Defect FDA Litigation Medical Device News Pharmaceuticals Preemption Product Liability Recalls Regulatory Settlements
/

Life Science Matters

Litigation

This Week’s Life Science Headlines

February 28, 2014
/
Design Defect FDA Litigation Medical Device News Pharmaceuticals Product Liability Recalls Regulatory
/

Life Science Matters

Litigation

J&J, Ethicon Sued Over Surgical Stapler Misfire (subscription required)
GSK Can’t Shake Calif. County’s Avandia False Ad Claims (subscription required)
Pradaxa Lawsuits Raise Questions Over Clinical Trial Data Accuracy
Firms Kick Off Benicar Diarrhea Suits Against Daiichi (subscription required)
Mirena Birth Control Lawsuit Filings Approach 1,000 Cases
Boston Scientific Obtryx Sling Lawsuits Consolidated for Trial
Zoloft False Ad Suit Time-Barred, Judge Finds (subscription required)
J&J Hid Topamax Birth Defect Risks, Philly Jury Hears (subscription required)
Total, Endo Units Hit With

This Week’s Life Science Headlines

December 13, 2013
/
Design Defect FDA Litigation Medical Device News Pharmaceuticals Product Liability Recalls Regulatory Settlements Verdicts
/

Life Science Matters

Litigation

High Court Denies Bid to Review Neurontin RICO Rulings (subscription required)
Merck Settles Fosamax Jaw-Injury Claims for $28M (subscription required)
Boehringer Fined $1M For Withholding Docs in MDL (subscription required)
Expert Testimony Must be Backed By Science, Pa. Court Rules (subscription required)
High Court Passes on Lupron Labeling Suit (subscription required)
1st Circ. Ends Takeda FCA Suit But Limits Scope of Ruling (subscription required)
Medtronic Escapes Jury’s $18M Surgical Fire Verdict (subscription required)
J&J Keeps Vaginal Mesh Suit Out of

This Week’s Life Science Headlines

December 1, 2013
/
Design Defect FDA Litigation Medical Device News Nutritional Supplements Pharmaceuticals Product Liability Recalls Regulatory Settlements
/

Life Science Matters

Litigation

Stryker Rejuvenate Lawsuits Filed by Nearly 1,000 Hip Patients Nationwide
Novartis Can’t Apply NJ Punitives Cap in 3 Zometa Suits (subscription required)
Pfizer Escapes FCA Suit Over Anti-Fungal Drug Promotions (subscription required)
Gardasil Lawsuit Filed in France Over Side Effects of HPV Vaccine
Judge Backs Jury Finding in J&J Body Powder Cancer Suit (subscription required)
OxyElite Pro Class Action Filed Over False Advertising
First Zoloft Trial in Federal MDL for Birth Defect Lawsuits to Begin Nov. 2014
J&J Takes Innovative,

This Week’s Life Science Headlines

November 22, 2013
/
Class Action Design Defect FDA Litigation Medical Device News Nutritional Supplements Pharmaceuticals Product Liability Recalls Regulatory Settlements Verdicts
/

Life Science Matters

Litigation

Remicade Lawsuit Filed Over Nerve Paralysis, Breathing Problems
GNC Hit with Suit Linking Supplement to Hepatitis (subscription required)
J&J to Pay $2.5B to Settle Hip Implant Litigation (subscription required)
$25M Hydroxycut Settlement Denied in False Ad MDL (subscription required)
J&J Unit Hit with Suit Over Rheumatoid Arthritis Drug (subscription required)
AMS Pelvic Organ Prolapse Mesh Lawsuit Set for Trial in August 2014
8^th Circ. Returns Boston Scientific Mesh Suits to Fed. Court (subscription required)
3^rd Cir. Affirms Plavix

Last Week’s Important Headlines

October 28, 2013
/
Design Defect FDA Medical Device News Pharmaceuticals Recalls Regulatory Verdicts
/

Life Science Matters

Here are some other notable decisions and developments from last week in the Life Science area: Litigation

Lipitor Lawsuit Filings Spike After Renewed MDL Request
Judge Trims Doc’s $2.2M Indemnity Suit Against Device Maker (subscription required)
High Court Won’t Hear Novo Foreign Liability Case (subscription required
Bulky Novartis Eyedrop Boxes Mislead Buyers, Calif. DAs Say (subscription required)
Transvaginal Mesh Damage Award of $2M Against Bard Upheld
Bard Pushes For Costs in Dropped Vaginal Mesh Bellweather (subscription required)

Regulatory

FDA Issues Positive Review for Gilead’s Hep

A Rock and a Hard Place: Court Rejects Drug Manufacturer’s Defense that Changes to the Label Required FDA Approval and Were Preempted

Susan E. Van Gelder

This week, a Florida federal court denied a drug manufacturer’s motion in limine to preclude a plaintiff’s alternative warning theory on the basis that any changes to the label required FDA approval and were preempted. Dopson-Trout v. Novartis Pharma. Corp., 2013 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 135834 (M.D.Fla. Sept. 23, 2013). During her treatment for breast cancer that had metastasized to her bones, the plaintiff was infused with Aredia and then Zometa. She then had her tooth extracted, after which she began experiencing jaw pain caused…
Continue reading...

Court Refuses to Scrutinize the Sufficiency of Differential Diagnosis Analysis and Permits Causation Testimony in Absence of Controlled Studies

September 25, 2013
/
Daubert Medical Device Pharmaceuticals Summary Judgment
/

Michael D. Shalhoub

This past week, an Ohio federal court considered under Daubert the standard by which specific causation experts in drug and device cases are to be scrutinized. While the Court precluded the opinions of certain experts who did not engage in a differential diagnosis analysis before forming specific causation opinions, it stopped short of precluding one expert who engaged in what was essentially an incomplete differential diagnosis analysis, concluding the sufficiency of the analysis goes to the weight of the evidence and not its reliability under…
Continue reading...

Florida Federal Court Allows Claim that Novartis Should Have Issued “Black Box” Warning on Zometa

Life Science Matters

A United States District Court Judge, sitting in the Middle District of Florida, has rejected arguments by Novartis Pharmaceutical Corporation (“Novartis”) that federal law would prohibit claims that the company should have added “Black Box” warnings regarding potential side effects of Zometa, including potential bone loss. As a result, plaintiffs will be allowed to proceed with their claims notwithstanding the company’s arguments (1) that all of the failure-to-warn claims were controlled by the Supreme Court’s 2009 decision in Wyeth vs. Levine; and (2) that…
Continue reading...

Life Science Matters An inside look at the latest legal developments involving medical devices, pharmaceuticals, and more

California Court of Appeals Rules Plaintiffs Can Pursue Claims Against Novartis for Alleged Damages Arising From Ingestion of Generic Drug Six Years After Novartis Divested its Interest

This Week’s Life Science Headlines

This Week’s Life Science Headlines

This Week’s Life Science Headlines

This Week’s Life Science Headlines

This Week’s Life Science Headlines

Last Week’s Important Headlines

A Rock and a Hard Place: Court Rejects Drug Manufacturer’s Defense that Changes to the Label Required FDA Approval and Were Preempted

Court Refuses to Scrutinize the Sufficiency of Differential Diagnosis Analysis and Permits Causation Testimony in Absence of Controlled Studies

Florida Federal Court Allows Claim that Novartis Should Have Issued “Black Box” Warning on Zometa

Multicounty Litigation Order in New Jersey Provides No Guidance to Practitioners June 23, 2021

New Multicounty Litigation Application in New Jersey June 8, 2021

Lack of Agreement to Arbitrate Dooms Bid to Compel Arbitration May 26, 2021

Mixed Bag in New Jersey Medical Device Preemption Opinion May 12, 2021

First Circuit Agrees Pharmacists Provide Services, Not Sell Goods April 27, 2021